onestopenglish
PDF

Description

Tips and suggestions for teaching relative clauses in English.

Relative clauses 

Present and past participle forms (e.g. talking, made) can be used without a pronoun or auxiliary to form a participle relative clause, e.g.

Do you know the boy talking to Thomas?

The participle relative clause underlined in the example has the same meaning as a defining relative clause with the relative pronoun who, e.g.

Do you know the boy who is talking to Thomas?

A participle relative clause with an –ing (present participle) form can be used like a defining relative clause to identify which person or thing you are referring to, e.g.

The house has three bedrooms. The bedroom overlooking the garden … (= which overlooks the garden)

-ing participle clauses also often show what someone or something is, or was, doing at a particular time, e.g.

Who were those children waiting outside? (=  who were waiting outside) Police investigating the robbery are asking people to come forward. (= who are investigating the robbery)

Participle relative clauses with an -ed (past participle) form are also used like defining relative clauses to identify a particular person or thing. They have a passive meaning, e.g.

The woman injured in the accident was expecting a baby. (= who was injured in the accident) All cakes sold in the café are made on the premises. (= which are sold in the café)

It is also possible to use participle relative clauses as non-defining relative clauses which add information. Like other non-defining relative clauses, these participle clauses are surrounded by commas, e.g.

His first novel, published in 1965, was an immediate success. (= which was published in 1965)

John’s father, lying on the sofa, was trying to take a nap. (= who was lying on the sofa)

Activity: /hu:z/

The word /hu:z/ can be tricky for students as it can mean who is (contracted = who’s), who has (contracted = who’s) or whose. Here is a sample restricted practice exercise to differentiate between the three. The sentences in this exercise are all based around the topic of hotels. Teachers could make their own sentences.

  • The receptionist is the person /hu:z/ responsible for reservations.
  • Do you know anybody /hu:z/ worked in a hotel?
  • There is a 10% discount for guests /hu:z/ reservations are made on the internet.
  • Is there anybody in the class /hu:z/ stayed in a luxury hotel?
  • /hu:z/ luggage is this?
  • That’s the guest /hu:z/ plane arrived late.
  • The hotel manager, /hu:z/ not here today, is the person you need to talk to.

Answers

  • The receptionist is the person who’s responsible for reservations.
  • Do you know anybody who’s worked in a hotel?
  • There a 10% discount for guests whose reservations are made on the internet.
  • Is there anybody in the class who’s stayed in a luxury hotel?
  • Whose luggage is this?
  • That’s the guest whose plane arrived late.
  • The hotel manager, who’s not here today, is the person you need to talk to.

Activity: The place where and the day when

The relative adverbs where, when and why can be easily incorporated into a personalization practice exercise like the following.

LIFE CHANGING MOMENTS

Can you remember …

  1. A day when you made a big decision?
  2. A person who had a big influence on you as a child?
  3. A place where you learnt something very important?
  4. A reason why you have your current job?
  5. A reason why you didn’t choose a different career?
  6. A time when you had to choose between two important things?
  7. A moment when you felt that history had been made?
  8. A time when you didn’t worry about the future?
  9. A place where you met someone very important to you?

Choose three of these memories and tell a partner about them.

Example

I remember the place where I first met my wife very well. It was a …

A variation which gives learners more control over the content is the following:

Complete the blanks with information that is true for you.

  • ___ is the day in my country when___.
  • ___ is a person I know who ___.
  • ___ is the room in my house where ___.
  • ___ is a time of year when ___.
  • ___ is the part of my town where ___.
  • ___ is the reason why ___.

Now rewrite the words from the first column on a blank piece of paper. Work with a partner. Show the words to your partner, but not the sentences. Can he/she guess why these things are important?

Activity: Interpretations

Because the information imparted can be very different depending on whether or not the relative clause is defining or non-defining, it is an ideal situation to check different possible interpretations of a sentence. Here are some examples of this kind of exercise. Teachers can make their own examples using names or contexts familiar to their students. 

Read the sentences. Then decide which option, a or b, is correct.

  • My sister, who lives in Los Angeles, is a designer.a) I have one sister.b) I have more than one sister.
  • The athletes who tested positive for doping were suspended.a) All the athletes tested positive for doping.b) Some athletes didn’t test positive for doping.
  • Flat screen televisions, which are very expensive, have a better image quality.a) All flat screen televisions are very expensive.b) Some flat screen televisions are cheap.
  • The teachers at this school who arrive late for class will be suspended.a) Only some teachers arrive late for class.b) All the teachers in the school arrive late for class.
  • The company president who works in Berlin is moving to London.a) There is only one company president.b) There is more than one company president.

Variation

Give students the follow-up sentences, a or b, and read the main sentences aloud. This way you can emphasize the pausing and intonation of the non-defining relative clause.

Activity: Elaborate the sentences

This is a creative sentence building exercise to practise non-defining relative clauses. Divide the class into small groups. Give each group one of the sample sentences below. Their job is to add one or more non-defining relative clauses to the sentence. Ask groups to compare, reading out their final versions.

1. The princess kissed the prince. 2. The doctor had a glass of whisky. 3. The mayor drove a very expensive Jaguar. 4. The football team’s captain cried after the match.

Here are some examples of what might emerge from sentence 3:

The mayor drove a very expensive Jaguar, which he had bought with the taxpayer’s money. The mayor, who was rich before she won the elections, drove a very expensive Jaguar. The mayor drove a very expensive Jaguar, which was a gift from a prominent businessman. The mayor, who was a communist in the past, drove a very expensive Jaguar. The mayor, who had connections with the city’s mafia, drove a very expensive Jaguar.

Teachers can make their own sample sentences for students to elaborate.

Click for More

Relative clauses in English – tips and activities

Last Update 08/14/2006

Premium

Buy Premium plan to access the following materials

This lesson has 1 files

(1)

Buy Offline Package

اگر قصد خرید پکیج مربوط به این درس را دارید اینجا کلیک کنید