LESSON OVERVIEW
My way or the highway!In this lesson, students will discuss a boss-centered management approach and the advantages and disadvantages of this style. The lesson features a video about the autocratic management style. Students will learn and practice vocabulary related to the topic. The lesson includes plenty of engaging discussion activities and worksheets developed for both adult and teenage learners, ensuring a comprehensive and interactive learning experience.
LESSON OBJECTIVES
Listening: Through the provided video on autocratic management, students will improve their listening skills by comprehending and analyzing how this leadership style functions. They will listen for key phrases that describe communication dynamics and control in a workplace.
Speaking: Students will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of working under autocratic leaders. They will engage in role-playing activities to simulate communication in a controlled, boss-centered environment and share opinions on the potential impact on team productivity.
Vocabulary: The lesson introduces vocabulary terms like “authoritarian,” “compliance,” “top-down,” “legitimate authority,” “centralize,” and “high-power distance.” These words are crucial for discussing leadership approaches, communication styles, and team management.
Cultural Awareness: Students will explore how different countries view authority in workplaces. They may discuss how generational shifts may influence future leadership styles.
Homework: Students will fill in blanks with vocabulary learned in the lesson, answer questions about their views on autocratic leadership, and analyze various management scenarios to determine where this style would be beneficial or detrimental. They will write T/F responses, complete multiple-choice questions, and provide detailed explanations. This will reinforce their understanding and application of the lesson concepts.
VIDEO
What is the best type of leadership style at work or in school? Is it the autocratic, democratic, or laissez-faire approach? Watch this video to learn about the autocratic leadership style and the advantages and disadvantages of these approaches to leadership.
VIDEO TRANSCRIPT
A basic description of the autocratic style goes like this. It is an authoritarian, boss-centered approach to leadership and management. The term autocratic is perhaps more commonly used than the term authoritarianism, but essentially, they mean the same thing. These leaders assume full control of the group, the goals, and the decisions. These leaders centralize decision making and power. Some researchers describe this approach as an absolute control approach for the leader over the entire operation. When it comes to communication, it’s no surprise that they have a top-down approach, and they dictate instructions, policies, and activities to the group. And they expect followers to comply. It’s a control compliance relationship. These leaders take little or no input from group members. They are not asking followers for their feedback. They make decisions based upon their own perspective of a situation. When it comes to decision making, I picture the autocratic leader coming to a room and just telling people what to do. In terms of how they relate to followers, autocratic leaders establish a high-power distance between themselves and everybody else. There are clear unequal power dynamics going on between the leader and the followers. And that’s because these leaders rely heavily on their positions of authority. French and Raven call this legitimate authority. When you are an official manager, you have a job description that explains your official authority and responsibilities that come with that position. The autocratic leader’s power, in other words, comes from their job title. In contrast, autocratic leaders don’t rely on their strong relationships and influence to lead. You don’t usually see autocratic leaders socializing and connecting with their followers in warm ways. They don’t eat meals together with subordinates for example, they don’t get to know them personally very much. They distance themselves relationally from others in ways that show that inequality. So, let’s talk more about the research by Lewin and his coauthors. These authors did experiments leading groups of 10-year-olds, in fact, and to me, it’s interesting that this research started with a teacher-student dynamic. If you think of the various teachers that you have had over your life, it’s possible that some of them had an autocratic style. The children were put into a number of small groups, and they were asked to perform various tasks like making theatrical masks, painting murals, carving soap, and making model airplanes. The adults then acted as the teachers and used a variety of leadership styles with those groups: autocratic, democratic, and laissez faire styles. The researchers then watched how the children responded to the different leadership styles. They also interviewed the children and the parents to get their perspective on how their experience was under each leader. So what exactly did they find? Well, this early research had mixed results, but it laid the foundation for how we still, to this day, think about autocratic leaders. Under autocratic leaders, followers were more aggressive toward each other. And in some versions of the experiments, the children were 30 to 40 times more aggressive than they were under a democratic leader. This was at times a general aggression among all the group members, but was sometimes focused on one particular group member where say four members of the group ganged up on a person a scapegoat to the point where that participant quit the group. Participants tended to be more productive when the autocratic leader was watching them and directly supervising them. But there was usually a sharp rise in aggression when the autocratic leader left the room. In other experiments, participants were much more resigned and apathetic, and they did get aggressive under an autocratic leader. They basically shut down.
VOCABULARY AND PRONUNCIATION
- my way or the highway [idiom]: said to assert the view that there is no alternative (apart from leaving) but to accept the speaker’s opinions or policies
- boss-centered management approach [noun phrase]: a type of leadership in which the manger has total authority to make decisions
- autocratic [adjective]: relating to a ruler who has absolute power
- assume [verb]: take or begin to have (power or responsibility)
- centralize [verb]: concentrate (control of an activity or organization) under a single authority
- democratic [adjective]: relating to the idea that all people should be treated equally
- laissez-faire [adjective]: the policy of leaving things to take their own course, without interfering
- sharp rise [collocation]: sudden growth or increase
- morale [noun]: the confidence, enthusiasm, and discipline of a person or group at a particular time
- customary [adjective]: according to the customs or usual practices associated with a particular society, place, or set of circumstances
- subordinates [noun]: a person under the authority or control of another within an organization
- establish [verb]: set up on a firm or permanent basis; put in place
- high-power distance [noun phrase]: a situation where there are clear boundaries and roles, and inequality is accepted and expected among members
- control-compliance relationship [noun phrase]: a situation in which when a person usually defers to the wishes of another, even if that’s what they wish to do
- shut down [verb]: to stop; to make ineffective
